"Does my business need a website if I already have a Facebook page and a Google Business Profile?" Owners ask this constantly, and the honest answer is: it depends on how you get customers, what each one is worth, and how much risk you can accept on platforms you don't control. This article gives you a straight way to decide, with a seven-question test, the actual math, and what to build if the answer is yes.
The question is more live than ever. In BrightLocal's SMB Marketing in 2025 survey of 778 US small businesses, more owners marketed on Facebook (50%) than had a dedicated website (40%). Half of American small businesses are running the experiment for you. Some are right to skip the website. Many are quietly paying for it in lost calls they never see.
What Facebook and Google Profiles Do Well
Facebook pages and Google Business Profiles are excellent at being found and weak at closing. They put you on the map, collect reviews, and answer quick questions; they don't control the story a serious buyer sees next.
Give the platforms their due. A complete Google Business Profile is the highest-value free asset in local marketing: in BrightLocal's Consumer Search Behavior study (2026), 52% of consumers started their most recent local business search on Google and 71% used Google at some point during it. For a "pizza near me" style purchase, the profile can carry the whole transaction, and a social presence adds the human face.
Here's the limit. Profiles are standardized by design. Yours looks structurally identical to your weakest competitor's, and you can't add a pricing explainer, service-area pages, a portfolio organized your way, or a lead form that asks qualifying questions. Buyers notice: in BrightLocal's Local Consumer Review Survey (2026), 54% of consumers said they visit a business's website after reading positive reviews. That click is the buyer verifying you're real and worth the money. If it lands on nothing, or on a Facebook page last updated in March, some of those buyers quietly move on, and no report ever tells you.
The Rented-Land Problem
Everything you build on Facebook or Google sits on land you rent, and both landlords have recently changed the rules without asking. That risk, more than any marketing stat, is the core argument for owning a website.
Two recent examples are worth knowing. First: Google used to offer free one-page websites built from Business Profile data. Google shut those sites down on March 5, 2024, and the redirects to profiles stopped working that June 10; after that, visitors hit a "page not found" error. Businesses that treated the free site as their web presence had weeks to replace it. Second: organic reach on Facebook pages has collapsed. Socialinsider's analysis of 872,075 brand posts (January 2025–August 2026) put Facebook's average organic reach around 1.8% of page followers, drifting down to roughly 1.25% by August 2026. A page with 2,000 followers reaches about 25–35 of them per post unless you pay.
Add the risks owners learn the hard way: hacked or restricted pages with near-unreachable support, profile suspensions that take weeks to appeal. None of this means abandoning the platforms. It means they should feed a destination you own, not be the destination.
There's also a newer reason: AI search. ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overviews compose answers from web pages they can crawl and cite. A Pew Research Center study (July 2025) found users clicked traditional results on only 8% of searches that showed an AI summary, versus 15% without one. When fewer clicks are available, being the source the answer engine quotes matters more, and answer engines quote websites, not Facebook posts. We cover that shift in our guide to getting found in AI search.
So, Does My Business Need a Website? A Seven-Question Test
Score yourself honestly: one point per yes. Five or more points means a website will likely pay for itself within a year; three or four means start with a simple one; two or fewer means your profiles may genuinely be enough for now.
- Is your average sale over $200? Higher-ticket buyers research before contacting anyone.
- Do customers compare two or more providers before choosing? Comparison shoppers need more than a profile to pick you.
- Do you need to explain anything — process, pricing logic, service areas, what's included? Profiles have nowhere to put explanations.
- Does your work photograph well, with sequence or context that matters (before/after, projects, menus, room types)? Galleries you control beat a jumbled photo tab.
- Do you want leads captured while you're working or closed? A form with qualifying questions works at 11 p.m.
- Would losing your Facebook page or Google profile for three weeks materially hurt revenue? If yes, you need a channel no platform can switch off.
- Do you plan to run ads in the next year? Ads landing on a purpose-built page convert better and cost less per lead than ads pointed at a profile.
Notice what's not on the list: "everyone says you need one." A food truck that sells out daily from Instagram, or a subcontractor fed entirely by two general contractors, can score 0–2 and legitimately skip the website until something changes. The point of the test is to make that a decision, not a default.
What a Website Costs vs. What It Returns
A simple small-business website typically runs $3,000–$6,000 to build professionally, plus hosting and upkeep, and the return question comes down to how few extra jobs it must produce to break even. For most service businesses, that's one or two a month.
Consider a hypothetical two-person exterior cleaning company. Say the site costs $4,000 to build and $40 a month to run: about $4,480 in year one. Assume it draws a modest 300 visits a month — clicks from the Business Profile, searches the profile alone can't rank for, and those review-readers above. Assume 3% of visitors call or submit the form, a normal rate for a focused local-service site: nine leads a month. Close a third at an average $280 job: three jobs, roughly $840 a month, about $10,000 a year against $4,480 of cost, before any repeat business. Each assumption is deliberately conservative; cut the traffic in half and the site still clears break-even. If your average sale is $45, the same math may never work, which is exactly what the test above is for. For a fuller breakdown, see what a small business website actually costs.
The honest caveats: a site produces nothing while it has no traffic, so months one through three are usually quiet. A cheap site that loads slowly or looks dated can perform worse than no site. And the build price buys presentation, not visibility — ranking for competitive terms is a separate, ongoing effort (that's SEO, and it compounds slowly).
The Minimum Viable Website: Five Pages That Do the Job
You don't need 30 pages; you need five that answer a buyer's real questions and make contacting you effortless. Anything beyond this list is optimization, not necessity.
- Home: who you serve, where, and why you, with your phone number visible without scrolling and the same name, address, and phone details your Google profile uses.
- Services (one page per major service if you offer several): what's included, how the process works, and honest price anchoring ("most projects run $X–$Y").
- Proof: photos of real work, reviews pulled from Google, credentials, insurance or licensing.
- About: faces and names. Local buyers hire people, not brands.
- Contact: a short form (name, contact, what they need, timeline), tap-to-call, and your service area stated plainly.
Two technical non-negotiables: the site must be fast on a phone, where most local visits happen, and every page should answer its core question in its first two sentences so skimming humans and AI answer engines can both quote it cleanly. This is the brief we build from in website design and development projects.
Your First 90 Days: Profiles and Website Working Together
The website doesn't replace your profiles; it gives them somewhere to send people. The first 90 days are about wiring the three together.
Days 1–30: launch the five pages, add the link to your Google Business Profile and social bios, and set up free analytics so you can see where visitors come from. Days 31–60: build a simple routine where every finished job becomes a photo on the site, a Google profile post, and a social post pointing back to the relevant service page; ask every happy customer for a Google review and quote the best on your proof page. Days 61–90: read the numbers. Which pages get visits? Which produce calls? Write one page answering the question customers ask most, then judge whether paid ads or more content comes next. That sequencing is the core of a real marketing strategy, and it gets much easier once you own the destination.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I just use my Google Business Profile as my website?
You can operate without a site; the profile handles discovery, reviews, hours, and calls. But Google retired its free profile-based websites in March 2024, and a profile can't hold pricing explanations, galleries organized your way, or lead forms. If buyers compare providers or spend real money with you, the profile alone leaves gaps a competitor's site will fill.
A Facebook page is free and a website costs thousands. Doesn't that make Facebook the smarter choice?
Facebook is free to start but pays back less each year: organic posts now reach under 2% of your own followers on average, per Socialinsider's 2026 study, so sustained visibility there is effectively pay-per-reach. A website is a one-time cost plus modest upkeep, and its pages keep working in search for years. Use Facebook for presence and conversation, not as your foundation.
Do I need a website if all my work comes from referrals?
Referrals still get checked. A referred buyer typically looks you up before calling, and what they find either confirms the recommendation or plants doubt. A modest five-page site raises the close rate on referrals you were already getting. If your pipeline is one or two contractual relationships rather than a flow of individual referrals, you can reasonably wait.
Will a website help me show up in ChatGPT and AI search results?
It's close to a prerequisite. AI tools build answers from pages they can crawl and cite, and your own site is the one place you fully control what they read. Pages that state plain answers — services, areas, pricing ranges, FAQs — are the format these systems quote. Social profiles contribute far less because their content is fragmented and often behind logins.
What's the cheapest legitimate way to get a website?
A DIY site builder runs $15–$40 a month and can produce a respectable five-page site if you invest a weekend and use real photos of your work. The trade-offs are your time, generic design, and weaker search performance. It still beats having nothing. Upgrade to a professional build when leads justify it or when you start paying for ads that deserve better landing pages.
Put This to Work in Your Business
Style Strand Media designs fast, lead-focused websites and the marketing systems around them for businesses across North Myrtle Beach and the Grand Strand, and for remote clients anywhere. If you scored five or higher on the test above, let's talk about what your version of the five-page site looks like.



